The Uncomfortable Truth About Why You're Overqualified (And Why That's Making It Worse)

You see the post and immediately recognize yourself in it: "Take my application seriously. I know I'm overqualified, but I need this job. I'll work hard. I promise I won't leave." The comments explode with agreement. "Yes! In this market, you take what you can get!" Everyone's nodding along, fighting for the right to be considered for jobs beneath their skill level.

But here's the part nobody wants to hear: the employers rejecting you for being overqualified aren't wrong.

This episode goes where most career advice won't—into the uncomfortable territory of why fighting for limitations is keeping you stuck, and why the market being hard doesn't mean you should aim lower. It tackles the posts everyone's seeing, the narrative everyone's buying into, and the desperate energy that's quietly repelling the very opportunities people need most.

The reality is harsh but necessary: when you're truly overqualified and you're telling employers "no really, I want this low-paying role," you're operating from a shrunken version of yourself. You didn't accumulate all that experience and those qualifications just to convince someone you'll be satisfied doing work that doesn't use your skills. But external circumstances—the headlines, the doom posts, the rejection emails—got into your head, and now you're parroting a narrative that isn't serving you.

Here's what's actually happening: your brain thinks it's solving an easier problem by aiming lower. "I'll just take anything" feels simpler than "How do I communicate $400K worth of value to justify a $200K salary?" But when you can't even land the lower-paying jobs, your brain spirals into worthlessness. The longer you stay there, the worse it gets.

This episode reveals the blind spot most people can't see: they're blaming the market when they actually haven't learned how to communicate their value effectively, put numbers to their contributions, or understand what different decision-makers need to hear. It's a skill gap disguised as a market problem.

What You'll Discover:

• Why employers are right to be skeptical when you apply for jobs you're overqualified for
• The identity shift that happens when your brain goes "desperate" (and why you don't like that version of yourself)
• What "I just put together some PowerPoints" really means when you dig deeper
• The four types of decision-makers and why generic value communication falls flat
• Why trying to solve an easier problem (getting anything) is actually harder than solving the right one

Ready to stop fighting for limitations and learn to communicate value that justifies what you actually want to be paid? Watch the training: How to Finally Value Yourself and Get Paid What You Deserve in 2026 at asknataliefisher.com/workshop-2026

Listen to the Full Episode:  

SUBSCRIBE FOR WEEKLY INSPIRATION ON

APPLE PODCASTS | SPOTIFY